Will My First Fresh Pumpkin Pie Be My Last?
Sunday, December 13th, 2009I’m not ashamed to admit I’m a bit of a “Martha,” but my favorite projects, recipes, etc. are those that look or taste impressive, but really aren’t too much work. Before this year, I would have completely scoffed at making a pumpkin pie from a real pumpkin … rather than from a can. But this was the year I finally planted a garden and as I mentioned in the “seed” post, I felt like my homegrown pumpkins deserved a more fitting end than the trash.
“A Googling” I went, and found this helpful site that gave a very detailed, step-by-step guide for making a pie from fresh pumpkin. Was it as much of a pain in the tooshy as it sounds? As I was making it, I thought … well … absolutely, yes it was. But honestly, in hindsight, it wasn’t at all difficult. It just required an extra hour or so and some extra dishes (stove-top steamer, food processor, utensils).
Sure … extra time isn’t something many of us have. And who likes extra dishes? But then again, the results were pretty amazing. I think partly because the recipe on the site is good, but this pie also tastes fresher and better … brighter is another words that comes to mind … than one from a can. The pumpkin itself is beautiful after it’s been cooked and processed … especially when you see how gross the pumpkin looks in the can.
Will I do it again? Sure, but I think only with pumpkins from my garden … if I had to buy a pie pumpkin, I think I’d just get a can instead (or my neighbor is a Aldi’s shopper and they have a pretty amazing frozen pie). And, of course, it would need to be at a time when I wasn’t in a huge hurry … like say when prepping for a holiday meal.
P.S. For those of you that don’t like pumpkin pie, I recommend you try a slice warm from the oven or warmed in the microwave for 15 or 20 seconds. I’d hated it for 38 years, but tried the Aldi’s pie I mentioned above warm from the oven. It was delightful, and now I’m a pumpkin pie fan.



















